Alex Noel explores why so many young men are being drawn into a culture of dominance, conspiracy, and hostility toward women — and why its growing influence matters for Christian women navigating faith, relationships, and a rapidly shifting cultural landscape.
Louis Theroux’s documentary Inside the Manosphere sheds an uncomfortable light on the male influencers known for disseminating misogynistic content across social media channels, podcasts and websites. Its main proponents include figures like Andrew Tate, as well as a whole host of others who are just as notorious, at least within the Manosphere itself. Drawing heavily on the film The Matrix for its central idea, this inspires the term ‘red-pilled’, which means to wake up to the realities of the world as the Manosphere sees them. Namely, that men are oppressed by women and therefore unable to succeed within this paradigm. Its ideology aims to empower men to ‘man-up’ and wrest back their sense of agency and control, whilst directly confronting the feminism which is seen to favour women at men’s expense. They exhort ‘traditional values’ emphasising male superiority and encouraging men to dominate women. All while peddling extreme macho rhetoric full of language which belittles and devalues women to put them ‘back in their place’.
READ MORE: Toxic masculinity is everywhere but a soft rebranding is not the answer
Misogyny is not the only form of hatred that the Manosphere incubates.
Misogyny is not the only form of hatred that the Manosphere incubates. And it is also a breeding ground for conspiracy theories. At one point, Louis interviews a young influencer known as Sneako whose videos garner billions of views. Recently converted to Islam; his ideology is now backed by his religious convictions. But it is a different belief that seems to carry more weight for him than the teachings of Islam. He explains that he believes a satanic cult is running the world whose symbolism appears in art, music and advertising. To many, Louis Theroux included, this sounds far-fetched; but to Sneako it helps him make sense of the world as he sees it.
As is the case with many conspiracy theories, there is a kernel of truth, albeit wrapped up in some wild distortions and misguided conclusions. In its simplest form this idea echoes a foundational biblical truth: that Satan, a fallen angel who has existed since before time began, influences the ways of men; scheming against humankind; operating both in the ‘spiritual realms’, and in and through the powers, structures and systems of a fallen world. [Ephesians 6]
READ MORE: When Andrew Tate met Bonnie Blue: faith, feminism, and the fight for truth
It is Satan too of course, who appeared as a snake in the garden of Eden, tempting Eve to question God’s command not to eat fruit from the Tree of Knowledge. Convinced by his reasoning, Eve ate the fruit, giving it to Adam too - and disobeyed God. At which point both their eyes were opened and they became conscious of their shame and nakedness before God. The aftermath of the Fall led to broken relationships and created the endless power struggles which have pitted men and women against each other ever since. And arguably has, by extrapolation, played a part in why the Manosphere exists. But this ‘curse’ also planted a longing in us for liberation and an intuition that we may never solve this problem for ourselves. That we need a saviour to redeem us, who cannot be tempted by Satan nor his promises of power and influence.
It’s clear, from the documentary’s interviews with influencers and their dedicated followers alike; that many come from broken families or poor backgrounds, or have absentee fathers; which is fundamentally disempowering in anyone’s experience.
It’s clear, from the documentary’s interviews with influencers and their dedicated followers alike; that many come from broken families, poor economic backgrounds or have absentee fathers; which is fundamentally disempowering in anyone’s experience. It is also this fact that makes the Manosphere’s message of empowerment and ‘tough love’ so compelling. And these young men especially vulnerable to the misogynistic ideologies which accompany the belief that power, dominance and wealth are the answer to their legitimate need for significance and validation.
READ MORE: What will boys be?
Reactions to the documentary have been varied. One reviewer identifies just how close those in the Manosphere are to uncovering reality; “inches away” in fact. They correctly diagnose that the odds are stacked against a whole generation of young men who are being robbed of their agency and power by a system that doesn’t value them and prevents them from succeeding, But the mistake they make is to then blame women for this. Such scapegoating obfuscates the truth and prevents those who have ‘taken the red pill’ from genuinely addressing the issues that keep them stuck, and from standing side-by-side with women as they fight to do so.
No comments yet