With allegations against high-profile men dominating the headlines, it can be tempting to see men as the enemy. Hope Bonarcher reflects on the dangers of putting men on pedestals and why Christian women must remember that we are all in need of God’s grace.

Contrasting British Celebrity Portraits

Source: 16/09/23 of Russell Brand leaving the Troubabour Wembley Park theatre in north-west London. Contributor: PA Images David Walliams London, England on November 22, 2021. Ref: LMK386-J7605-231121 Gary Mitchell /Landmark Media

Growing up, I was what you’d call ‘boy crazy’. Looking back, I was a perfect case study; my mum’s only child, from a lineage of mostly girls on my dad’s side. I was happily feminine, totally boy-averse. Until I turned 13. A switch flipped, and a whole world I’d never considered opened.

In my American teens, a show called My So-Called Life brought Claire Danes to fame, and alongside her, a very heartthrobby, seventeen-year-old Jared Leto. His blue eyes and grungy hair were a cross between James Dean and Kurt Cobain.

My first crush in Jr High was a real-life Leto lookalike. He was a skateboarder, emanating cool, effortlessly. The new girl at school, when he took my number and said he would call, I awaited, giddily. Then… mortification. When my mum answered the phone, a weird throat thing inexplicably occurred at the same moment. Her “hello” came out like a croak, followed by hoarse coughing. She apologised, laughed and handed the phone over.

I’d rehearsed this moment in my head like any other young teen, with the utmost gravity. The fantasy hadn’t included my future Romeo asking, confused, “Was that your mum? Sounds like she’s got a frog in her throat.”

READ MORE: Russell Brand, rape allegations and repentance: Can we believe someone has really changed?

I could have tapped out of life in that moment, completely. It was just the beginning of my awkward history with the dashed expectations of boy worship.

Today’s man seems to have teetered into the abyss, from heartthrobs to monsters. The aforementioned Jared Leto is only one of a slew of men fallen from the high place of glory and prestige attributed to male celebrities. A BBC documentary featured four women who accused the adult Leto of criminal sexual conduct while they were teenagers. Leto has categorically denied the allegations.

Actor, comedian and pop star Katy Perry’s ex-husband, Russell Brand, was sentenced to ten years and six months in a UK prison for rape and sexual assault. Famed British author David Walliams, whose books have sold more than 50 million copies, faces allegations of inappropriate workplace behaviour, sexual harassment and grooming teenage girls, all of which he denies.

READ MORE: Russell Brand’s alleged crimes are horrific – I’m desperately sad but given what boys were taught about sex, I’m not surprised

The long list of men promoted to power being disgraced seems never-ending, leading to the seemingly valid question: Are men the enemy?

The long list of men promoted to power being disgraced seems never-ending, leading to the seemingly valid question: Are men the enemy? When we raise any individual or group of humans above scrutiny, they will crash down, staggeringly. Christians should be the least surprised by this, yet we forget the clear biblical edict of our nature – wicked, fallen, hopelessly beyond self-repair or redemption.

“The Lord saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intention of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually. And the Lord regretted that He had made man on the earth, and it grieved Him to His heart” (Genesis 6:5–6).

Believing women can’t gloss over the fact nearly every example of faithfulness and godliness we have in the Bible was an undeniably flawed man. Moses was a murderer whose struggle with unrighteous anger kept him out of the Promised Land (Deuteronomy 32:51). The namesake of the tribe of Judah hired his daughter-in-law as a prostitute (Genesis 38). King David allowed for the murder of an innocent man; some would even argue him a rapist (2 Samuel 11–12).

What about this telling verse concerning the most prolific apostle? “Saul was one of the witnesses and he agreed completely with the killing of Stephen” (Acts 8:1). Biblically speaking, the only surprising thing about the propensity for men to act terribly is not their ability to sin, but God’s ability to consistently and patiently strive alongside and forgive them.

READ MORE: Lucy Beaumont fears being silenced over David Walliams allegations – but what does the Bible say about women speaking out?

So, are women holier than God?

So, are women holier than God? “Let he who is without sin cast the first stone” – Jesus (John 8:7). It’s a temptation of feminism. Christian women must never offer ourselves before the Lord as totally righteous apart from Him. Recently, I came across a great piece by one of my favourite Substack authors, Shervin Youssefian. He argues in “The Bible NEVER says woman was made from man’s rib” that Old Testament Hebrew never actually says the word “rib” for what Eve was created from. Instead, the actual translation of the word is “side”.

I found the piece a revelation. If it’s true, woman wasn’t created from a completely different substance than man (bone vs dirt) but from the exact same material – equally inestimable, equally malleable, equally fallen. We are all predisposed to sin. There was equal representation at humanity’s fall. Sin wasn’t instigated by males, but by our real enemy, the Deceiver, and sinful humans’ collectively willing heart of disobedience.

It’s because of this, no celebrity idol or gender is worthy of worship, apart from Jesus. He is the true and necessary redeemer for all men and women.